News, ideas & conversations for communicators worldwide
 

« Obama’s inept and shady PR team, part I | Main | Sam Zell needs a good corporate editor »

The media are bum referees

Have you ever played a sport marred with bad officiating? The referee, umpire, line judge—pick your sport—constantly botches calls.

Then recognizing he has missed a penalty, the official starts blowing his whistle at the slightest hint of contact. These are makeup calls. The official is overcompensating—making up—for the calls he missed earlier in the game.

Makeup calls ruin a contest.

The media are bad officials who rely heavily upon makeup calls. Just look at poor Tony Snow. His death made headlines. He was, after all, White House Press Secretary. Many media and PR pros insist he was even one of the best.

But his death couldn’t rival that of Tim Russert, who, I think was sainted—or was it martyred? I can’t remember. The media did this hilarious thing with Russert coverage. They broke it as if it were news the moon had exploded.

A couple days later the backlash arrived. And the press were backlashing themselves. Too much Russert coverage, they screamed. As if they never give meaningless events—at least in terms of the world—too much coverage.

And Tony Snow is the victim. He was a makeup call, an easy one too. Coverage of his life and death would be respectful, but pundits and columnists wouldn’t spend too much time on it. They don’t want the Russert rap again, plus Snow was just a shill for Bush, right? And Bush is so 2003 anyway.

If only Snow had some connection to Obama—or that new Batman movie.

Poor, poor Tony Snow, I don’t even think I remember who he is anymore. Isn’t he that motivational speaker with the big smile? That guy died? Man, I loved that guy.

Comments (7)

Anonymous:

For all commenters that can't seem to pass up the oppotunity to hyperventilate about the war, the Bush Administration or the country in general: I'm sure there are some message boards at moveon.org that would love to have you.

Just a thought.

ann:

didn't pay attention to their deaths, it didn't affect me. people die every day no big whup.

T.O.:

Tony Snow got a good amount of respectful coverage and a certain degree of disrespectful coverage in his death. Tim Russert got better treatment. Both seemed like good guys and upon their deaths, you couldn't have run enough good stuff about either in my opinion. The only attention they were stealing was from the likes of Paris Hilton and Brittany Spears in the celeb-crazed media.

The one thing that may have hurt Snow in the media, other than his status as a conservative, was his positive confidence in maintaining control in his dealings with the media. His skill in this area was something every PR person should aspire to, however, reporters who are used to always having the upper hand tend to resent guys like Snow and look for the first opportunity to bring them down. In this case, a few had to wait until Mr. Snow couldn't speak for himself.

Mac:

You can't win for losing, huh? Both Tim Russert and Tony Snow seemed like nice, genuine guys. And it's sad when folks die young like they did. Legitimate story, at some reasonable level.

But here's an interesting question for you PR folks: when someone like Russert or Snow dies, well-liked and respected within the industry, at what point is it allowed to point out that both of them helped lie the country into and continue an unjust, brutal, society destroying war?

Melvin McCoy:

So an Obatman story is akin to a flagrant, can't-miss technical while everything else is tickytack, homer, and/or dependant upon who the media has their money on.

Foul indeed.

Thanks Wilma! As you'll notice, the changes were made.

Wilma Mathews:

"Media" is plural; "medium" is singular.
"The media are bad officials who rely heavily..."
"The media are bum referees"

Post a comment

Important:
to protect against spam you must enter the letter "s" in the box.
(The comment will be posted ONLY when the safety letter is entered.)

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on July 21, 2008 5:50 AM .

The previous post in this blog was Obama’s inept and shady PR team, part I .

The next post in this blog is Sam Zell needs a good corporate editor .

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Comment Feed Subscribe to this blog's feed
[What is this?]

Recent Responses

Jon
Would Abraham Lincoln ever pass Obama's vetting process?
I have to think today's media would have uncovered all or most of this WAY before Abe was even handed this questionnaire...
read all | post a response

rachel
Does this Motrin ad offend you?
Mom of two big babies here. "Wearing them" was definitely not a pain-free experience, but c'mom. You're outraged? Offend...
read all | post a response

FEATURED VIDEO

Former Reagan speechwriter Peggy Noonan sits down with Jon Stewart on The Daily Show.

Blogger Bios

Posts by Author

About

Tell us how you manage unrealistic expectations, meet reporter needs, churn out news when there is none, deal with a client you can't stand, and what you say to people that slam PR. Or anything else that's on your mind.

Ragan Blogs

Content Matters
- Toby Ward, Tim O'Keefe, and Todd Whitley

PR Junkie
- Melissa Underwood, Michael Sebastian, and Mark Ragan

Other Blogs

- Shines a brighter light on the subtle roles played by public relations
- A gathering place for professional communicators
- Blogging at the intersection of communication and technology
- Ranting and raving about news, techniques, and development in the world of PR research and evaluation.

PR Newser

- PRNewser is a blog about Public Relations

- The latest and most effective strategies to market your business.

- Business communications for the real world

- The place at the intersection of business, communication and technology.
- Les Potter blogs about Strategic Communication and Public Relations

- Social Network for PR Students, Faculty, and Practitioners

- An award-winning public relations resource

- Conversations about Social Media and Marketing

- What would the LEAN Communicator do?

Powered by
Movable Type 3.33

Home | Internal Communication | Public Relations | Speechwriting | Web Content | Government Communication | Tips & Tactics | Hot Topics | Back to Top
MyRagan | MyManageresNetwork | MyRaganTV | Blogs | Podcasts | Jobs | Forums | eNewsletters
About Us | Copyright 2007 Ragan Communications, Inc. | Privacy Policy | Search | FAQ | Contact Us | Store | RSS RSS | Widgets | Site Map